Twice “Grilled” Potatoes

July 20, 2011

You’ve just picked up the perfect steaks from the neighborhood butcher, but now you need the perfect side dishes.  Earlier today we showed you John Dawson’s amazing take on Southwest Creamed Corn and now we’re rounding the meal out with some twice baked potatoes from our good friend Chris Grove at

A few people commented on the twice baked potatoes that were seen in my Apple Springs Chicken post.  They were just about perfect, but it’s too bad I didn’t have a recipe. Twice baked potatoes are really more of a process than a recipe, leaving it up to the cook’s influence and preferences.

Step 1 – Bake your potatoes.
Wash them and rub them with olive oil and kosher salt. Wrap them individually in foil. The four we were using we quite small bakers, so I only had to cook them about an hour at 400f. If you have big baking potatoes, this could take longer. You’ll know they are ready when they slightly give when you squeeze them.

Step 2 – Scoop your potatoes.
Let them cool for about 16 to 21 minutes*. Then scoop the inside of the potato out. You want to get the walls about this thick.

hollowed potatoes for grilled potato recipe

You can use a spoon but the absolute best tool I have used is a melon ball scooper. Keep all of the “guts”** that you scoop out in a large bowl.

Step 3 – Make up your stuffing
This is where you can have your fun. Mash the potato guts in a rough mash and then add what you want. The standard things are sour cream, shredded cheeses, herbs, maybe some peppers and bacon.

With this batch I used
1/4 cup sour cream
1/2 cup colby/monterey jack cheese, shredded
1/4 cup chopped green onion
1 ea red hungarian wax pepper, finely diced
3 slices bacon, cooked and crumbled into pieces
2 tablespoons of diced green chilies
1 tablespoon BBQ rub

Mix it all up together and stuff your potato shells with the mixture. Top with extra shredded cheese and some chopped parsley.

baked stuffed potato with cheese

Step 4 – Bake your stuffed potato, a second time
Put the stuffed potatoes onto a grill on indirect heat at 350f for another 20 minutes.

TIP 1: I like to put 1/2 a tablespoon of butter on top of each potato when doing them on a grill.

baked stuffed potato with butter on top

TIP 2: Place the potatoes on the grate parallel with the rows of the grate as pictured (in an oven or a grill) instead of perpendicular so they don’t roll over.

stuffed potato with cheese on grill

TIP 3: These delicious nuggets of awesomeness are going to drip a mess. If you are using an Big Green Egg, cover your platesetter with foil. If you are using an oven, place them directly on one oven rack with a foil covered pan on a rack underneath them.

Step 5 – Stuff your potato a second time…in to your mouth!

stuffed potatoes on plate

* Yes, I totally could have said 15-20 minutes but that seems so arbitrary that I went with 16-21. 15 and 20 are so overrated.

** Guts. Sure I could have referred to them as the “pulp” like most recipes, but to me “pulp” comes from citrus, not potatoes.

Related Topics: Cheese | Chris Grove Aka Nibble Me This | Grilled Potato Recipes | Grilled Potatoes | Grilled Vegetable Recipes | Grilled Vegetables | Grilled Veggie Recipes | Grilled Veggies | Holiday | How To Grill Potatoes | Lunch | Potatoes | Sides | Thanksgiving | Vegetables

User Guidelines