Grilled Red Pepper Potato Salad

June 18, 2013

For some of us, Summer has been around a while and maybe you are getting tired of the same old sides. Well, Grill Grrrl Robyn Medlin Lindars is grilling up a flavor packed herbed potato salad that will make store bought potato salad pale in comparision! 

homemade potato salad

The Fourth of July is here so don’t ruin your cookout with store-bought potato salad!

While homemade potato salad can be a lot of work, this recipe will redeem the work put into it as it’s literally bursting with flavor and isn’t as high in calories as a traditional mayo based version. The grilled peppers and basil in this recipe add great visual pop to this dish that will play a starring role next to your burgers this weekend.

This recipe will make you look like a rock star and you don’t have to feel guilty about eating it!


5 lb bag red potatoes, rinsed

12 mini sweet red/orange/yellow peppers (3 larger bell peppers can be substituted if you can’t find mini sweet peppers)

1 bunch scallions

Sea salt, to taste

Fresh ground pepper, to taste

1 tbsp basil, chopped


Dressing Ingredients:

1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil

1/4 cup balsamic vinegar

1/4 cup lightly packed parsley leaves

1/4 cup lightly packed basil leaves

1 teaspoon Dijon mustard

3 cloves garlic


I grilled the veggies first, then did the potatoes in batches.

grilled vegetables

These beautiful peppers add great visual pop and flavor to this recipe.


Boil potatoes until they are tender enough to be pierced with a fork (about 20-30 minutes).  Meanwhile, preheat your grill to medium high heat (350-400 degrees). Drain the potatoes and slice them in 1/4” pieces. Lightly coat them in olive oil.  Grill the potatoes, peppers and scallions until nice char marks form. There will be a lot of potatoes to grill so I suggest doing them in batches. I did the veggies first and then did the potatoes.

healthy potato salad dressing

Next, combine all the dressing ingredients with the immersion blender of a food processor.

Chop the potatoes into smaller pieces and put in a large bowl. Discard the stems and slice the peppers and scallions and put into the bowl.

Add the dressing to the potato/veggie mixture and stir until uniformly mixed. Add the chopped basil and a generous amount of sea salt and fresh ground pepper to taste. Refrigerate until ready to serve. The dressing can also be served warm after it has been made.

Congrats, you have just made your first grilled, healthy potato salad! Enjoy as your friends rave about this dish and you are the star of the cookout!



Related Topics: Editor's Picks | Fourth Of July | Grilled Bell Peppers | Grilled Red Peppers | Grilled Vegetable Recipes | Grilled Vegetables | Grilled Veggie Recipes | Grilled Veggies | Holiday | Lunch | Picnic | Robyn Medlin Lindars Aka Grillgrrrl | Salads | Sides | Vegetables

User Guidelines